The Butcher Shoppe has experienced multiple expansions since its inception, guided by the leadership of Mr. and Mrs. Koons, their son Terry Koons, their daughter Mary Sue Keath, and her husband, Frank Keath. In the middle of 2006, Mr. and Mrs. Keath acquired all the company's shares, assuming sole ownership. Frank and Mary Sue retired in 2017, and ownership of the store transitioned to their daughter, Anne Schoenhofen, and her husband, Leo. As the third generation of ownership, the Schoenhofen family remains dedicated to upholding the mission and business principles originally established by Anne's parents and the company's founders, who were Anne's grandparents.